Filters

Star Ratings

Price (per night)

Review Score

Property Type

Hotel Facilities

Room Facilities

Places

Foster Memorial Beach Atlantic Golf Course Channing Daughters Winery Sag Harbor Whaling Museum Sag Harbor Station Uptown Pilates Sag Harbor Bay Street Theatre First Presbyterian Church Bridge Gardens Nathaniel Rogers House Custer Observatory Osprey's Dominion Vineyards Manhanset Chapel Henry W. Prince Building Old House Shelter Island Country Club Fairview Farm Mashomack Preserve Union Chapel

122 hotels

Sort by:

Cancel Sag Harbor Sag Harbor- Show on map

Avg. price/night

$362

Guest House- South Hampton North Sea- Show on map

Swimming pool
Garden

Baron's CoveSag Harbor- Show on map

Very Good, 8.0

(268reviews)

Room service
Pet friendly
Swimming pool
Private beach
Elevator / Lift
Parking

A Walk in the Woods Bed and BreakfastSouthold- Show on map

Very Good, 8.0

(20reviews)

Bicycle rental
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$301

Bridgehampton InnBridgehampton- Show on map

Fabulous, 8.7

(209reviews)

Restaurant
Garden
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$223

North Fork Bayview Vacation Rental Southold- Show on map

Fitness center
Spa

The Enclave InnBridgehampton- Show on map

Restaurant
Swimming pool

The Pridwin HotelShelter Island Heights- Show on map

Good, 7.3

(275reviews)

Bar
Swimming pool
Babysitting
Wi-Fi

North Fork Guest HouseCutchogue- Show on map

Exceptional, 9.9

(129reviews)

Wi-Fi

Sunset BeachShelter Island Heights- Show on map

6.0

(133reviews)

Room service
Pet friendly
Private beach
Babysitting
Wi-Fi

Shelter Island HouseShelter Island Heights- Show on map

Fabulous, 8.7

(25reviews)

Room service
Swimming pool
Spa
Garden
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$401

White Fences Water MillWater Mill- Show on map

Exceptional, 10.0

(105reviews)

Swimming pool
Garden
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$293

Sag Harbor Beach Guesthouse Sag Harbor- Show on map

Private beach

Charming Lakehouse in SouthamptonNorth Sea- Show on map

Garden
Wi-Fi

Forever BungalowsWainscott- Show on map

Very Good, 8.0

(170reviews)

Garden
Wi-Fi

Capri North SeaNorth Sea- Show on map

5.4

(108reviews)

Swimming pool
24-Hour reception
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$829

Heron Suites at Port of Egypt MarineSouthold- Show on map

Very Good, 8.0

(146reviews)

Swimming pool
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$233

The ChequitShelter Island Heights- Show on map

Superb, 9.2

(180reviews)

Garden
24-Hour reception
Wi-Fi
Parking

Sylvan Guest House HamptonsSag Harbor- Show on map

24-Hour reception

Topping Rose HouseBridgehampton- Show on map

Superb, 9.4

(58reviews)

Room service
Swimming pool
Spa
Private beach
Garden
Elevator / Lift
24-Hour reception
Babysitting
Bicycle rental

Avg. price/night

$440

380 InnWainscott- Show on map

Good, 7.7

(110reviews)

Swimming pool
24-Hour reception
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$237

Sweet Dreams Bed and Breakfast Cutchogue Cutchogue- Show on map

Latch Pop-Up Inn Southampton- Show on map

Good, 7.2

(15reviews)

Swimming pool
Garden
24-Hour reception
Wi-Fi

The Bridge Inn - Bridgehampton Bridgehampton- Show on map

Very Good, 8.0

(16reviews)

Swimming pool
Garden
Wi-Fi

Harbor Knoll Bed and BreakfastGreenport- Show on map

Swimming pool
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$476

Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter IslandShelter Island Heights- Show on map

Exceptional, 9.9

(94reviews)

Swimming pool
Garden
Bicycle rental
Parking

Avg. price/night

$382

Southampton Long Island HotelTuckahoe- Show on map

Good, 7.5

(288reviews)

Swimming pool
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$164

Southampton Escape North Sea- Show on map

Southold Beach MotelSouthold- Show on map

6.8

(80reviews)

Garden
Wi-Fi

Avg. price/night

$181

Historic White Blossom HouseSouthold- Show on map

Garden
Wi-Fi

1 of 5

William Cauldwell House

Find hotel discount code and book direct

Filters

Loading...